Idea to increase more fighting

[Ozaru]

Here is an idea that I wanted to get some feed back. Primarily I join a cabal for the simple benefits of medic scrolls and defender potions. Now a good portion of the time there is no one to fight because of the lack of pbase. Now what if we had a system where if you killed a cabal member you had access to their cabal supplies. or maybe even just killing the guardian which would then make you anathema or contracted or maybe even uncompliant for keepers no one would kill justice because that is just silly. So with these added incentives maybe we would get an increase in over all fighting because you want access to these potions and scrolls. Curious to see what you think.

[Esivole]

I see where your going, and i won't say that its a horrid idea. The issue I see though, is that cabals are made to have those benefits to balance the negatives (cabal defense, missing items, 12 people invading, player activity and so on.) It would give an unfair advantage to those elitists who can generally shrug off a cabal flag for 6 hours of sanc. Not to mention there would have to be a coding change to the cabal item itself, as right now if you kill a cabal member and get some stuff from the corpse (or be a lowbie vulture,) you still can't use them. I just don't see an overall benefit to it.